Peyton Manning, a frequent playoff nemesis of Brady as an Indianapolis Colt, was more successful in the head to head . Current Search. Tom Brady is the only quarterback to be starting quarterback for record 9 AFC championships, while Peyton Manning has only started 4 AFC championships, 2 for each of the two franchises he played. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback has won a total of 34 playoff . Jake Plummer outdueled Brady and the Pats in the 2006 divisional round, 26-13. But those records could be broken on. Tom Brady can join Peyton Manning, Drew Brees and Brett Favre as only QBs in NFL history to beat every team. By any statistical measure, Tom Brady and Peyton Manning have performed at a nearly identical level in the postseason. Most people tend to forget that Peyton Manning actually has a winning record against Tom Brady in the Playoffs - including a 3-1 record vs. Tom Brady and the Patriots in AFC Championship games (the game befor. The two combined threw for over 9,000 yards, and 60 touchdown passes in their head to head matchups per SportingNews. The ratings adjuster program didn't begin until 2018, after Manning retired, and didn't start incorporating former NFL players -- Chad Johnson is the most active adjuster of the NFL alumni -- until last year. Tom Brady holds the overall edge in terms of wins in the Tom Brady vs Peyton Manning rivalry. But hold the phone - Manning was 6-5 in his last 11 starts against Brady, including a 3-1 overall record in AFC Championships, which is the biggest game these two could have played since they were . One thing to know: Peyton Manning and Tom Brady have one of the richest rivalries in the history of the NFL. Tom Brady Playoff Stats Vs Peyton Manning | StatMuse Tom Brady has a passer rating of 90.4 with 12,449 yards, 83 touchdowns and 38 interceptions in 45 games in the playoffs in his career. For the people following the sports the closest during their careers, Manning was better than Brady during the regular season. Tom Brady when given a prolific offensive weapon like Randy Moss he has proven to show the ability to put up the same high numbers like Peyton Manning. All 17 Brady vs. Manning box scores, combined into one. That is a lot of yards and a lot of touchdowns in 17 career meetings. Stage: AFC divisional playoffs. Peyton Manning wouldn't even make my short list. Here are all the active streaks of at least 50 touchdowns that include at least one active . Manning ranks . Joe Montana, who has a playoff Passer Rating over 96, won 16. Data coverage: all-time (since 1920). Oremland makes a compelling argument as to . It has Tom Brady at 7th and Peyton Manning at 1st. Scoring statistics (TD, XP, FG) are complete all-time. The 22 wins are a record for postseason wins by a QB, six ahead of Joe Montana. By the Indianapolis Colts in the 1st Round (1st Overall) in the 1998 Draft. Despite Tom Brady's great record of 10-4 against Peyton Manning, he is 5-6 in his career vs. the Denver Broncos (including playoffs). 9. Will Joe Burrow vs. Patrick Mahomes be the Peyton Manning vs. Tom Brady 2.0? Peyton Manning-Tom Brady ranks among greatest sports rivalries of all time. 01 Brady vs. Manning in the playoffs. Indianapolis finished 12-4 behind a NFL record 49 TD passes from Manning. Brady won the first two playoff matchups in the 2003 and '04 seasons, with Manning taking home victories in the last three (2006, '13, '15 seasons). At this point, Tom Brady has more Super Bowl rings, while Peyton Manning has higher statistical totals. Edge: Brady.This is probably closer than most fans realize but the advantage is clear. Brady vs. Manning may be the most famous quarterback battle in NFL history. November 2, 2014 - Week 9 - NE 43 - DEN 21 Recap: Tom Brady can keep adding to the record books. For the first half of the 2000s, Manning vs. Brady was the football version of Maria Sharapova vs. Serena Williams—a rivalry in name only, defined by one side's overwhelming dominance. Peyton Manning (DEN, 2013) 5,477 . Peyton Manning's 12-13 playoff record isn't indicative of his overall performance level. The real fun statistic is that Manning has a 3-1 record against Brady in AFC Championship games, 2 . Tom Brady has 12 playoff wins with a passer rating over 100 and 15 with a passer rating over 90. Otto Graham holds the record for the highest winning percentage with a minimum of 50 starts at .814 (57-13-1). 10. Manning, at that stage of the game, was universally regarded as the best QB in the game, but lacked any type of playoff success having just lost to Brady and the Patriots and the year before suffering a 41-0 loss to the New York Jets. … Manning also won a record five MVP awards, Brady three. If I had the choice of picking a quarterback, I would pick Tom Brady. Manning had a 3-2 record against Brady in the playoffs. Manning's passer rating is 17% better than the league average during his career, Brady's 15%. Get in touch with us now. Brady owns 2003-04 AFC Championship Game and 2004-05 Divisional Round. PATRIOTS 24, COLTS 14, January 18, 2004 New England was favored by 3.5 at home, and grabbed a 15-0 halftime lead in coasting to victory. Brady: 18-of-27, 144 yards, 1 TD The 37-year-old quarterback shattered both the NFL single-season records for passing yards and passing touchdowns en route to winning his fifth NFL MVP award and leading the Broncos to the Super Bowl. Peyton Manning won 14 playoff games during his entire career. Active quarterback Tom Brady holds the record for the most regular season wins with 243. Tom Brady is the NFL's all-time leader in playoff wins, touchdown passes, passing yards and completion percentage. Brady won the first six, but Manning's taken four of the past five. One of the game's first adjusters was the son of an NFL legend -- Barry J. Sanders, a former Stanford running back. Yardage and attempts statistics were not recorded until 1932. who broke another Manning record. Only 12 players in NFL history have career winning records . Please see our data coverage page for details. Manning had 4,985 passing yards, 35 touchdowns and 22 interceptions. 1 / 5. Tom . #STATS * Peyton Manning: Peyton Manning * Tom Brady: Tom Brady Manning is a career 65% passer to Brady's 63%; Manning averages slighly more yards/attempt (7.7 to 7.5); Manning throws more TDs (5.8% to 5.5%); Brady avoids INTs better (2.0% vs. 2.6% for M. Brady's knee injury last season put the rivalry on hold, but the two resumed their rivalry on Sunday. Basically, if Brady and Gronk can't do it, then Manning's right, the record is probably unbreakable. The Broncos are one of only two teams in the NFL to have a winning record against Brady (the Giants are 3-2 vs Brady, including playoffs). Not what you're looking for? Only one quarterback in NFL history has faced Brady five times and has a winning record -- Peyton's brother, Eli Manning (3-2). 230. Brady has the upper-hand, winning 10 of the 15 meetings, but Manning evened the playoff series . Tom Brady makes playoff history, joins Peyton Manning on this rare list of Super Bowl quarterbacks. The first time Tom Brady outdueled Peyton Manning in the playoffs, perhaps his most critical contribution came with his legs, not his arm. The Tom Brady-Peyton Manning "rivalry" was a series of games that took place between 2001 and 2015 involving two quarterbacks in the National Football League (NFL): Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. Patriots 20, Colts 3. Peyton Manning is next on the list with 27. Tom Brady is widely heralded as one of the best American football players of all time. Brady currently holds the advantage over Manning in their head-to-head competition, boasting a 9-4 record, including 2-1 in the playoffs. Stew Milne/US Presswire The inescapable postseason factor. Manning Win/Loss Record with QB Rating < 80 (including playoffs): 28-48. Want the stats? But used against the argument Brady fans make, Manning going 3-2 vs. Brady in the playoffs is a major trump card. A rivalry for the ages. , Feb 8, 2021. The Broncos are one of only two teams in the NFL to have a. Tom Brady. Who Is Better Peyton Manning Or Tom Brady? … Manning also won a record five MVP awards, Brady three. Tom . Manning is just 12-13 with nine one-and-dones, the most ever for a QB. 55: Manning's single season touchdown passes record set in 2013, which broke Brady's record of 50 set in 2007. Tom Brady has better numbers in his 2 Super Bowl losses than Peyton Manning has in his 4 Super Bowl Appearances combined. 1 seed Broncos struggled to . Players Stats Standings My Cause My Cleats Draft . This weekend's AFC Championship Game between the Patriots and Broncos is the 17th meeting between Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. In many ways, the legendary QB's postseason numbers surpass those of Tom Brady, writes Scott Kacsmar. When: Jan. 16, 2005, at New England. Playoff record: Brady 22-8, the most postseason victories for a quarterback in NFL history. It has John Elway at 12th overall. 2005-2015 Brady 14-9 in playoffs, 1-2 in SB, Manning 12-7 in playoffs, 1-2 in SB's with 1 to be played. 225. Peyton Manning Height, Weight & Size Postseason Head-to-Head: Tied at 2 (Getty) Their playoff record, however, is even at 2-2. In addition to the passing yards record, Manning also set the single-season passing touchdown record, surpassing Brady's previous record of 50 touchdowns from the 2007 season with 55 scores. From these "only stats needed", Brady was better from 2000-2004 and Manning has been . Peyton Manning - who dropped to 0-4 vs Tom Brady with this. But those records could be broken on. Peyton Manning had a season for the ages in 2013. Brady would probably need to play a couple of years longer than . You should show that stat… Oh wait I have that stat compared to Manning! Manning's passer rating is 17% better than the league average during his career, Brady's 15%. When given the Superstar Randy Moss, Tom Brady was able to throw for over 4000 yards in each of the seasons they were together and 50 touchdowns in their first year. * denotes playoff game (H - Home, A - Away, these refer to home or away games for Peyton Manning) Tom Brady holds a 9-4 advantage all time in the win column including a 2-1 record in the playoffs. Facing a 21-6 deficit at halftime, Manning and the Colts rallied back in the second half, outscoring the Patriots 32-13 to punch their Super Bowl ticket. Though Brady has had much more playoff success overall than Manning has, when it comes to playing against one another, the results are split down the middle. 87.2: Career playoff passer rating for Brady, 12th highest all-time. Despite Tom Brady's great record of 10-4 against Peyton Manning, he is 5-6 in his career vs. the Denver Broncos (including playoffs). AP. Joe Flacco and Tom Brady are tied for the most road post-season wins (7). On Sunday, Peyton Manning and Tom Brady will face off for the 16th time in their storied NFL careers. Heading into the 2007 AFC title game, Brady held a 2-0 postseason record over Manning. "Tom Brady has just been an outstanding quarterback for such a long time, but the game next week is the Broncos vs. the Patriots," Manning said Sunday after the No. . Brady won six straight against Manning's Colts, from 2001-05. By the New England Patriots in the 6th Round (199th Overall) in the 2000 Draft. An average season for Manning was an 11-5 record, completing 65.3% of his passes for 4,231 yards, 32 touchdowns and 15 interceptions with a 96.5 passer rating. Tom Brady 108. 4 The number of times Brady and Manning faced . Ultimately, which one will be viewed as superior? The other major difference in these two careers is postseason play. Of course, many observers don't care about passing statistics, and prefer to judge quarterback based on playoff W/L record alone. Tom Brady holds the NFL record for most playoff wins by a quarterback with 34, and the record for most playoff games started (45). Answer (1 of 5): Personally, I don't think that it would have made much of a difference. See Below: Brady Win/Loss Record with QB Rating < 80 (including playoffs): 47-51. While Manning got the better of Brady in the playoffs during Manning's time in Denver, Brady's Patriots consistently beat down Manning in Indy. Since entering the league in 2000, Brady has played the equivalent of 2 1/2 seasons of postseason football with 40 games under his belt. Only Aaron Rodgers has three seasons of . He is also just one of five players in NFL history to record 5,000+ yards, 40+ touchdowns and a passer rating above 100.0 in NFL history. 3 . Over the course of his 22-year career, Tom Brady has broken a lot of NFL records, including the all-time pass completions mark he set on Sunday against the Bills, but there is one record that he's still chasing and if he ends up breaking it, it will definitely be notable and that's because it's a record that Hall of Famer Peyton Manning considered unbreakable when he retired from . March 7, 2012: Indianapolis Colts has been cut. Sunday's AFC Championship Game between the Patriots and Broncos was the 17th, and possibly the last, meeting between Tom Brady and Peyton . Tom Brady makes playoff history, joins Peyton Manning on this rare list of Super Bowl quarterbacks. On the game's opening series, facing fourth-and-1 from . 6. Brady has also played more playoff games (34, including the Super Bowl) than any quarterback. Looking at . Tom Brady 108. March 20, 2012: Denver Broncos has been signed to a five-year contract. Tom Brady's Patriots and Peyton Manning's Colts have matched up 10 times the decade, often resulting in classic games. He is also just one of five players in NFL history to record 5,000+ yards, 40+ touchdowns and a passer rating above 100.0 in NFL history. hen you see that most NFL pundits have in their top MVP candidates are two quarterbacks who . 38/39: Ages of Brady and Manning . Manning on the other hand might make the playoffs but I think he lacks the character necessary to win playoff games. New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady, left, chats with Indianapolis Colts quarterback Peyton Manning after the Patriots beat the Colts 27-24 Thursday, Sept. 9, 2004 in Foxboro, Mass. Basically, if Brady and Gronk can't do it, then Manning's right, the record is probably unbreakable. Brady's team bailed him out a hell of a lot more than Manning's did.